Looking to buy a new camcorder? Excited by the possibility of HD recording?
While camcorders have been around for a long time, the combination of HDTV capabilities with home camcorders has recently become more complicated for two reasons: storage formats and video formats.
Let’s start with storage formats. Traditional camcorders have used tapes. Early models used bulky VHS takes. which were superseded by the compact Hi-8 and VHS-C formats. As digital camcorders became mainstream, the MiniDV format caught on. Most early HD camcorders used the MiniDV format to record HDV video. Even though these cameras feature high video quality and all sorts of bells and whistles, they still inherent the same limitations inherent in tape-based recording. You cannot instantly jump to a clip of video recorded 30 minutes earlier. Importing into a computer takes as long as your video runs. These restrictions may not be problematic for those who tend to play video directly from their camcorder to their TV without editing, but the advantages of digital recording (including computer editing and simplified backup) are then lost.
Fortunately, manufacturers are beginning to realize this. Many cameras record to DVD or some miniaturized version thereof. This simplifies playback and computer transfer, but DVDs are not HD and tricks to record HD video onto them limit compatibility. Hard disk based recording is promising, offering potentially large amounts of storage in a compact package. The primary disadvantage is that you can’t bring a second hard disk with you if are on a trip and don’t have an opportunity to upload the video from your camera when you run out of space.
SD (Secure Digital, not Standard Definition) cards are wildly popular in digital cameras, but traditionally have not been used for video (particularly HD video) because of their limited data capacity. They are solid-state memory, with no moving parts to wear out. They offer rapid data access, a compact size, and easy transfer to a computer. Additional SD cards can be carried for a long trip. As a result of their speed, SD-based camcorders can often start recording within a second or two of being switched on.
SD sounds like the ideal format for video cameras, but adoption has been limited by the high price and relatively small storage capacity of SD. New SDHC (high capacity) cards promise to address the issue of limited capacity, but sizes above 8 GB are uncommon at this time. As of this writing, the two most popular SD-based camcorders are the Sanyo VLC-HD2
and the Panasonic HDC-SD1
. The Sanyo model is limited to the lower-resolution 720p HD format, and reviews of its predecessor were lukewarm, particularly with respect to image quality. This model is still new, and detailed reviews are not readily available. The Panasonic can compete with tape-based models, but some feel the quality still a step behind, due to the AVCHD format it uses.
AVCHD is a form of video encoding that is more efficient than the traditional HDV format, but reviews have criticized early AVCHD cameras for their quality. The main drawback of AVCHD is that computer software for editing AVCHD is still rather limited. It is expected that Apple will upgrade its video editing software to support AVCHD within the coming months, but this has yet to be confirmed.
Advice? If you are not bothered by (or prefer) a tape-based video recording system, then there are a wide range of options on the table, with the canon
leading the pack. If you are interested in moving to either hard disk or SD-card based recording, I would advise waiting to see how the AVCHD software support fares over the coming months. While the Sanyo VLC-HD2 avoids this format, the quality of video it offers is not yet known.